Maybe it’s my age, but I find myself being critical of stories where the characters can seemingly go for days without going to the loo. I mean, really. How many of us, get up, get dressed, and rush out of the house without stopping to pee? Let alone any other morning rituals – shower, teeth brushing, coffee, food.
I remember reading The Da Vinci Code and thinking half way through – hang on, this guy hasn’t been to the bathroom in days. Perhaps, in an adventure story, it’s not advisable to break the tension by having the characters shoot off to the toilet now and then. They certainly won’t have time for sex either (I think they did at some point in TDVC – but they must have been very smelly and dirty – not having had time to wash or go to the bathroom). And even writing a romance, where the action’s not taking place at breakneck speed, you don’t want to spoil the moment with the love interest saying, ‘Um, excuse me, I really have to go. Where’s the bathroom?” (And, of course, they never fart at inappropriate times.)
Do readers either want, or expect, realism? In writing stories, there has to be a balance, I think, between describing a character’s movements (not bowel ones) in enough detail to make them seem realistic, and boring the reader to death with too much information.
I was given a diary when I was young, eight in fact. It was a small book and there wasn’t much space for each day’s entry. I still have this diary and the entries are very succinct: ‘I played’. ‘I went to school’ (only I spelled school backwards – did I think my parents couldn’t decipher this?). The most descriptive one – ‘We had a horrible lunch’ – I wonder what that was (and maybe I hoped my parents would read that one!).
The diary did have some useful information in it though, which may be why I’ve kept it.
And my point is? Well, I didn’t write in the diary that I got up, went to the bathroom, brushed my teeth, ate breakfast…although I would have done all these things before ‘I played’ or ‘went to school’ or ‘had a horrible lunch’.
At the tender age of eight I realised that this was a given, so maybe I should just accept that it isn’t necessary for the writer to tell us that the character went to the bathroom before she set off to save the world, or whatever. I mean, it’s obvious. She would have had to. She might be able to leave the house without having a shower, coffee or food, maybe even forgetting to brush her teeth, but she would have had to pee. Or, is this just my age showing? There’s no way I leave the house without having visited the bathroom.
But, maybe not this one – it’s a bit too ‘outdoor’ for me.
(Note: the animal tracks stayed with me. When I got my first camera, some of my earliest photos were of animal tracks in the snow.)
Arc Over Time – available from Affinity eBook Press /Amazon.com / Amazon.co.uk / Bella Books / Barnes & Noble / Smashwords / iTunes
Starting Over – available from Affinity eBook Press / Amazon / Barnes & Noble / Bella Books / Smashwords / iTunes.
There Was a Time and The Christmas Sweepstake – both available FREE on the Affinity website
Interesting topic … amusing perspective … satisfying conclusion !!!
Loved it! I have put in that my characters retreat to the restroom for a breather. I guess they use it then too. 😄
Loved this and I think you are correct, shower, grooming, bathroom scenes are only relevant when they are supporting the story or characters in some way. Sometimes you can sneak something in that adds a bit of humor. Otherwise it may appear as if you are trying to boost your word count. I did add a few to my upcoming book Ou of This World. I too am more focused on these things as I get older.
Mine have taken showers. I assume they did other things in there, too! But no, didn’t mention peeing outright. Or the other, either. I guess I figured, like you did, that it was a given somewhere along the line.
I cracked up when I read your first couple of lines. In my newest book (to be released in the next couple of days), I have a character that needs to pee, RIGHT NOW. The thing is, her distress is part of the action of the scene. It’s one of the things that gives the scene added tension.
My gut take on the subject is, if it doesn’t add to your story, don’t include it. Readers know everyone goes to the loo, as you put it. It’s one of those things that’s assumed. I don’t bother with bathroom scenes unless a plot point turns on them or I can get tension or comic relief out of them.
Pingback: News Roundup: Rainbow Award honourable mentions, new books, events and a loo break | UK Lesbian Fiction